Every morning when I wake up, the first thing I do is open all of the windows and doors, letting as much of the cold morning air in as I can. In Oregon, it seems the mornings are always cool, no matter what time of year. It may very well be one of my favorite things about the place.
It’s a simple routine. One man, wandering around the place in his underwear, sliding open windows and propping open doors. Making coffee. Having a bowl of cereal. Checking his email, looking for comments, thinking about his day. It is almost always a quiet start.
But not every morning. Some mornings are different. Some mornings the other Imagined Keiths are standing there, just outside the front door, waiting for me to wake up. Not the one, Imaginary Keith, who lives with me. He is usually still asleep when it happens, which is good, because the sight of the others is too much for my friend. He loses his nerve and never knows what to say. No, the others are not him. They are the other Imagined Keiths, the ones who never quite made it. The ones who seldom have a voice, or don’t exist at all. The ones who maybe lived but a day and then disappeared, or lived only as expectations of someone else’s imagination.
And no matter how many times I open the door and find them standing there, I am always startled. Their presence catches me off guard. Nobody expects to find so many others standing at their front door when they open it in the morning, especially dressed only in underwear.
But the routine is simple. Just like me wandering the house, making coffee, and opening windows, the Imagined Keiths have their own morning routine. Each, in turn, will stand at the door and ask one question, and then wait for me to ask him a question in return. Once the two questions are asked, the Imagined Keith will turn and walk away, disappearing quickly down the street, and the next in line will step up and take his place, repeating the whole routine. It took me years to figure out that they never expected an answer, and even longer to figure out that they would never answer my own questions. In the beginning, when they first started showing up, I would sometimes follow one of them down the sidewalk as he walked away, especially if I’d asked what I thought was a particularly important question. I just knew he knew the answer, and I would beg and plead for an answer, but of course, never get one.
It was always the same. First their question, then my own. Turn and walk away. The only thing that changed was the number of Imagined Keiths who would show up. Sometimes it’d be only a few and the exchanges would last only a minute or two. Other days there might be hundreds, and the questions would go on for hours. I hated these mornings. They were exhausting, not to mention depressing. Some of their questions, after all, could be quite pointed.
This morning wasn’t too bad. A couple of dozen, maybe more, I’d given up counting them years ago. I’d even given up trying to keep track of them, which at one point in my life had seemed important. I’d started a list, writing down each and everyone of them, jotting down who they were and what they had become. I’d thought somehow it would all make sense, if I could somehow see all of them at once, on paper at least. Then, I thought, I might make some sense of my own life. If I could just understand all of the possible Keiths, I thought, maybe I might begin to understand the real Keith.
I gave up the idea after only a week, after all of the others begin to be too hard to tell apart. To me they all looked identical, and it was only after they’d asked their question that I would begin to think I knew who was who. But then it occurred to me that maybe they changed their own questions, and I really had no way of telling. Or that maybe there were an infinite number of Imagined Keiths, and that each day it was someone new. Maybe the same Imagined Keith never came back, in which case, the list would be useless. If that were the case, there would be no recognizable patterns, no repetition, and no answers to discern from the endless stream of questions.
The first asked his question as soon as I opened the door. Apparently an imagined version of myself that didn’t believe in wasting time.
“Do you think the maple will die in the back yard?” he asked.
“Do you think it matters?” I asked. He turned and walked away. Obviously others of me were concerned gardeners, and close enough to myself to know of the tree.
“How many children starve to death each day?”
“What’s for lunch?” After so many years of their questions, it sometimes came down to nothing more then a game of associated thinking, with me simply blurting out the first thing that came into my head.
“Should we pursue the matter?”
“Does it matter?”
“Should I take the new position or remain in Houston?”
“Houston?”
“If I ask her, what will she say?”
“Aren’t you wasting your time?”
“Should I prep the potatoes?”
“Sidetracked or side-tracked?”
“Should we assume the logarithm is correct?”
“What ever became of her?”
Some mornings the questions were quick and painless. They were simple questions, asked by versions of myself that I could recognize. Keiths that had remained in the kitchen. Keiths that remained close to children or stayed on as one version of laborer or another. Keiths that had followed one line of study in college, rather then bouncing from one thing to the next. Their questions seemed clearer and easier to follow. They were questions about easy decisions and things that mattered very little.
But not all mornings were the same. Some were not so simple. Mixed in among the easily recognizable might be another Keith whose question came from somewhere unknown. A question whose root was not so easily traced.
“Do I dare tell him the truth?”
“What can it hurt?”
“Will we make it on time?”
“When has it mattered?”
“Did you leave behind any fingerprints?”
“What are you talking about?”
“What can you do for twenty bucks?”
“Did you hear the last Keith’s question?”
“Is Wednesday afternoon work for you?”
“Do you guys ever talk to each other?”
“Will you ever forget?”
“Is it even possible?”
“Are you sure he’s dead?”
“Who’s dead?”
If I leave to go get coffee, they wait. If I have to stop and answer the phone, or go use the bathroom, it is not a problem. They seem patient to ask their questions, except of course, for the first Imagined Keith in line. But maybe they’re just anxious to get started, and once they do, they calm down. It’s really hard to say. I realized once that I had no real idea just how long they stood there outside my door before I would open it. Maybe it’s all night, or maybe it’s only a few seconds. Maybe they materialize out of thin air the moment the door swings open. Or maybe they are there all of the time, just waiting. Maybe their entire life is spent waiting to ask their one question, and then it is complete. Maybe this is all life really is, a chance to ask one question. Maybe we all live an endless amount of lifetimes, asking an endless amount of unanswered questions.
One time I imagined that there was another place, and another me, and that this other version of me would open his door in the morning and face his own line of Imagined Keiths. Only in this version, these others would walk up, one by one, just like they do with me, only instead of asking questions, they would give answers. And this other version of me, completely unaware of me and my endless amount of questions, would simply answer each answer with his own answer.
I tried to imagine what it would be like, to be this other version of me, and have all of the answers, rather then all of the questions. I wondered if it would be any different. I wondered if I would still think of the questions, now that I knew all of the answers. What would it be like, I thought, having answers with no questions?
“Do you think it’s even possible?” the last Imagined Keith asked me this morning. It seemed like he had been reading my thoughts all along, as he stood there in line, waiting his turn. Was it possible that imagined versions of myself, Keiths that might have been, somehow kept track of their own possibilities? Just who was real, and who was imagined?
“I think it might be,” I answered. He stood there, unmoving, waiting for a question, not an answer.
“Can I make it through this?” I asked. It seemed to be the question most on my mind. Without an answer, he turned and made his way down the sidewalk, his steps quick and determined. I wish I could be so determined, I thought, after asking my own questions. I wish I knew just what direction to turn and walk. I thought about chasing him down, maybe grabbing him and shaking an answer out of him. But I knew he would never answer. It wasn’t in him. I knew it. He had no answers, only a direction. I watched him disappear into the park, moving in and out of the trees until finally he was gone altogether.
One day I will follow them, I thought. I will follow them all. I will turn and walk out the door myself, moving in and out of the trees, one step behind all of my questions, until I too disappear. And then maybe I will know if there is a place with only answers. Maybe then I will stop asking questions, or know if I can make it through, or even if it matters.
But that will not be today. When the last of them are gone, I close the door, go into the kitchen, and pour myself a cup of coffee. They’ll be back. Maybe tomorrow, maybe not. There is no way to know.
Maybe my son and I will leave town this weekend, and find a place where there are no questions. Maybe we will just do nothing and laugh and listen to waves hitting the sand. Maybe for a day or two I will clear my head and stop wondering where the others go. Maybe somewhere in the time I will spot my own direction, and I will have the energy to turn and follow it.