I answered the the phone a few minutes ago and it was Herman Melville.
“Hello.”
“My good man, I’ve been calling now for months without success. Most vexing. I’m afraid to say I had all but given up on reaching you.”
“You had? Sorry. Who is this, by the way?”
“Why, Mr. Herman Melville, my dear sir. I’d heard you’d had a bit of run-in with that scoundrel, Dreiser.”
It’d been several months now since Dreiser had called. While I do remember him calling, I’m more than a little ashamed to admit that I can’t actually recall what it was we talked about.
“I believe in the end, everything was worked out for the best,” I lied to Melville. It does nobody any good to admit the failings of a spotty memory.
“Nonsense. Now ask me your question and let’s be done with it.”
“Ask you my question?”
“Yes. Ask me your question and I will answer it clearly and precisely using only quotes pulled from my work. Better yet, I will let you choose. You may choose from any piece other than Moby Dick.
Other than Moby Dick put me in a bit of bind. I’m even more ashamed to admit that a list of Melville’s work was even more fuzzy to me than my conversation with Dreiser.
“There are simply no clear answers in that story,” Melville said. “Now, choose.”
“I’m thinking,” I said, stalling for time.
“Perhaps you could ask your question while you think.”
“Good idea. How about, ‘How will I fair in the new year?’ How’s that?”
“Sir, that is perhaps as vague a question as I’ve ever had the misfortune of laying my ears upon. But asked, it will be answered as promised. Now, from where shall the answers come? Let’s get to it, man. The sea waits on no man, as they say.”
“Alright. How about Billy Budd?”
“I was more than hoping you would choose one of my poems. The Tuft of Kelp, perhaps, where I would have then replied, ‘If purer for that, O Weed, Bitterer, too are ye.’ “
“Yes, I see.”
“But if you’re set on Billy Budd, then Billy Budd it will be. Ask your question, and I will answer.
“How will I fair in the new year?”
“ ‘That is thoughtfully put,’ said Captain Vere.’”
“That’s the answer?”
“No, no, of course not. I was just warming up.”
“Yes, of course.”
“Okay, how about this? ‘...something in your aspect seems to urge that it is not solely the heart that moves in you, but also the conscience, the private conscience.’ Does that help clear things up for you?”
“Yes, thank you. I feel much better now, knowing that. I’m glad I finally answered the phone.”
“Yes, so am I, my good man. So am I.”